Products here are argued, not rated.

Anatomy of a verdict

1. Advocate

   Builds the strongest case for. Every claim must cite an evidence id, or it is dropped before anyone sees it.

2. Prosecutor

   Builds the strongest case against, from the same evidence base. Three rounds each — opening, rebuttal, closing.

3. Judge

   Runs on a different provider from both, so no single model’s habits decide the outcome. Scores evidence, not rhetoric.

3

Rounds

6

Arguments

0

Uncited claims

The structure of every debate on this site. It describes the process — no product claim is being made here.